EVs Facing Heavier Depreciation than Gasoline Counterparts
Smaller cars have experienced heavier depreciation over the past 12-18 months, but it’s the small mainstream electric vehicles that are experiencing even heavier valuation drops.
GOYLE
Black Book recently looked at the prices of a new Nissan LEAF vs. Nissan Versa; a Mitsubishi i-MiEV vs. Mitsubishi Lancer; Ford Focus Electric vs. Ford Focus; and a Chevrolet Volt vs. Chevrolet Cruze.
The electric car premium over a counterpart gasoline model for mainstream brands has pretty much disappeared for used vehicles from an average premium of $16,600 for new vehicles. In fact, in a few cases, a used electric model now costs less than its gasoline counterpart.
GOYLE
"On several of today's popular electric vehicles (EVs), the depreciation curve is very steep, largely driven by lack of consumer demand preferences for fuel-efficient models with current price of gas," said Anil Goyal, VP of Automotive Valuation and Analytics for Black Book. "Smaller cars have experienced heavier depreciation over the past 12-18 months, but it’s clear that the small mainstream electric vehicles are experiencing even heavier valuation drops."
Black Book Valuation Data on EVs vs. Gasoline Counterparts
(2012 New vs. Used)
Vehicle | 2012 NEW Equipped Retail | Electric Premium | Effective Retail After Federal Incentive |
|---|---|---|---|
Nissan Leaf SV 4D Hatchback | $36,380 | $20,287 | $28,880 |
Nissan Versa SL 4D Hatchback | $19,320 | $19,320 | |
Mitsubishi i-Miev ES 4D Hatchback | $29,125 | $19,887 | $21,625 |
Mitsubishi Lancer ES 4D Hatchback | $19,720 | $19,720 | |
Ford Focus Electric 4D Hatchback | $40,387 | $9,405 | $32,887 |
Ford Focus SE 4D Hatchback | $20,500 | $20,500 | |
Chevrolet Volt 4D Hatchback | $40,431 | $17,060 | $32,931 |
Chevrolet Cruze LT 4D Sedan | $20,144 | $20,144 |
* Used Value as Percent of New Effective Retail after Federal Incentive
Vehicle | 2012 Used Avg (7/15/15) | Electric Premium | Three-Year Retention* |
|---|---|---|---|
Nissan Leaf SV 4D Hatchback | $7,400 | ($900) | 26% |
Nissan Versa SL 4D Hatchback | $8,300 | 43% | |
Mitsubishi i-Miev ES 4D Hatchback | $5,350 | ($3,100) | 25% |
Mitsubishi Lancer ES 4D Hatchback | $8,450 | 43% | |
Ford Focus Electric 4D Hatchback | $10,250 | $1,150 | 31% |
Ford Focus SE 4D Hatchback | $9,100 | 44% | |
Chevrolet Volt 4D Hatchback | $10,500 | $650 | 32% |
Chevrolet Cruze LT 4D Sedan | $9,850 | 49% |
* Used Value as Percent of New Effective Retail after Federal Incentive
More Operations
Manheim Index Shows Used-Vehicle Wholesale Prices Up 2.1% in June
The market is seeing stronger appreciation in older used vehicles this year, and the most affordable segments have been among the year’s best performers.
Read More →
Commercial Fleet Sales Contribute To June, YTD Gains
The fleet sector has boosted its vehicle purchases at a reliable pace in the first half of this year compared with 1H 2025.
Read More →
Stop Remarketing Electric Vehicles Like Gas Cars
The advantages and attributes of electric vehicles are upending the traditional remarketing cycle, requiring fleet sellers to rely on new factors and approaches detailed below.
Read More →
AP Fleet Management Expands Remarketing Program for Commercial Work Trucks
AP Fleet Management expanded its commercial vehicle remarketing program with dedicated resale services and an online marketplace for used work trucks.
Read More →
Used EVs Strengthen Overall Electric Vehicle Market
The latest sales data point to several reasons for the divergent trends in new and used EVs that can factor into fleet cycling decisions.
Read More →
The Data-Driven Haul: 5 Ways AI is Leveling the Playing Field in Auto Transport
Large and small transport fleets are becoming more competitive as predictive analytics and real-time data inform the logistics decision chain.
Read More →
2026 CAR Awards Celebrate Industry Excellence
CAR’s annual Fleet Remarketing Awards opened a reimagined 2026 conference designed to bridge the worlds of fleet management and automotive remarketing.
Read More →
CAR 2026 Recap Part 2: Closing the Gap Between Data & Remarketing Value
The second half of CAR 2026 examined how fleets can translate lifecycle strategy, vehicle data, and market shifts into higher real-world results.
Read More →
CAR2026 in Two Words: Velocity, Value (Part 1)
The 2026 Conference of Automotive Remarketing convened with a mandate to involve a new constituency — fleet managers — and an updated mission to demonstrate unrealized value in de-fleeted vehicles.
Read More →
CAR 2026: Get the Wall Street Update on the Key Players in Remarketing
From a Wall Street analyst's take on remarketing's key players to whether fleets need their own version of Carfax, CAR 2026's afternoon roundtables will answer key operational and industry questions.
Read More →