Vehicle Remarketing Logo

Effort to Protect New and Used Car Buyers Revived in California

SACRAMENTO, CA – The Car Buyers' Bill of Rights, vetoed by Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger in September, will be back next year – both as a ballot initiative and as an Assembly bill, reported the Sacramento Bee newspaper.

by Staff
December 30, 2004
3 min to read


SACRAMENTO, CA – The Car Buyers' Bill of Rights, vetoed by Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger in September, will be back next year – both as a ballot initiative and as an Assembly bill, reported the Sacramento Bee newspaper.

A Democratic law firm this week took initial steps toward putting consumer protection for car buyers on the statewide ballot. And Democrats are also prepared to introduce a bill similar to the one Schwarzenegger vetoed, according to activists on both sides of the issue.

Ad Loading...

After an intense debate between consumer advocates and car dealers earlier in the year, the Legislature approved a bill that would have set minimum standards for certified used cars. Vehicles with that label could not have been totaled, returned under the state's lemon law, or had their odometers rolled back.

The bill also would have required new-and used-car dealers to put buyers' credit scores in writing and would have barred dealers from charging more than 2.5 percent interest above the rate that the buyers qualified for based on their credit.

In a move hailed by car dealers, Schwarzenegger killed the measure, AB 1839, written by Assemblywoman Cindy Montañez, D-San Fernando. The governor said the wording of the bill was too vague.

Consumer advocates criticized the veto, pointing to the roughly $1 million in campaign contributions car dealers and manufacturers had made to the Republican governor's campaign account.

Robin Johansen, the San Leandro lawyer who submitted the proposed ballot initiative to Attorney General Bill Lockyer's office, said she could not divulge whom she was representing.

Ad Loading...

"We have clients who think these are important issues that should go in front of the voters," said Johansen, whose firm often represents Democrats in high-profile political cases.

Democratic lawmakers have already said they are considering going to the ballot with other policies Schwarzenegger has vetoed, such as allowing Californians to buy prescription drugs from Canada.

The car-buyers' initiative submitted to the attorney general, a preliminary step before gathering signatures to qualify the measure for the ballot, contains even stronger consumer protections than the bill Schwarzenegger vetoed, reported the Sacramento Bee.

It reinstates a provision that was dropped from the bill that would allow used-car buyers to return their vehicles within a three-day cooling-off period. It contains a provision that used vehicles must pass a smog check before they can be sold. It also contains tougher penalties for defrauding military personnel, who often are scam targets.

"I think it's healthy for our democracy to involve people in this," said Rosemary Shahan, president of Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety, the group that sponsored the Montañez bill. "You could be scammed thousands of dollars in your car transaction and not even know it."

Ad Loading...

Shahan said Montañez is also reintroducing legislation similar to the bill Schwarzenegger vetoed.

Brian Maas, a spokesman for the California Motor Car Dealers Association, said the group was working on compromise legislation of its own. "We're disappointed to see the Car Buyers' Bill of Rights has been reintroduced as an initiative," he said. "We think fixing this problem in the Legislature is something that can be achieved."

Maas said car dealers are in favor of creating standards for certified used cars and cracking down on hidden charges in car financing. But they oppose other provisions, such as a $150 cap on dealer commissions for car loans and leases.


Topics:Operations

More Operations

Image of three award winners at 2026 CAR
Operationsby Faith HowellMay 6, 2026

2026 CAR Awards Celebrate Industry Excellence

CAR’s annual Fleet Remarketing Awards opened a reimagined 2026 conference designed to bridge the worlds of fleet management and automotive remarketing.

Read More →
A man standing in front of transparent tech screen with a the outline of a delivery truck.
TechnologyMay 1, 2026

The Predictive Pivot: How AI and Data Are Redefining Auto Logistics in 2026

AI is no longer a luxury but the baseline for profitability in 2026. Auto haulers that adopt these tools now will quickly outpace those that use manual workflows or take a wait-and-see approach.

Read More →
collage of conference speakers
Operationsby Chris BrownApril 30, 2026

CAR 2026 Recap Part 2: Closing the Gap Between Data & Remarketing Value

The second half of CAR 2026 examined how fleets can translate lifecycle strategy, vehicle data, and market shifts into higher real-world results.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Collage of CAR speakers
Used Vehicle Valuesby Chris BrownApril 27, 2026

CAR2026 in Two Words: Velocity, Value (Part 1)

The 2026 Conference of Automotive Remarketing convened with a mandate to involve a new constituency — fleet managers — and an updated mission to demonstrate unrealized value in de-fleeted vehicles.

Read More →
Graphic promoting CAR 2026 roundtables featuring headshots of five speakers and topics including Wall Street trends, fleet data, upfits, fair market value, and AI in remarketing.
Operationsby Chris BrownMarch 31, 2026

CAR 2026: Get the Wall Street Update on the Key Players in Remarketing

From a Wall Street analyst's take on remarketing's key players to whether fleets need their own version of Carfax, CAR 2026's afternoon roundtables will answer key operational and industry questions.

Read More →
Promotional graphic for CAR 2026 panel on data-driven value in commercial vehicles, featuring five industry experts and session details for April 16 in Cleveland.
Fleetby Chris BrownMarch 31, 2026

CAR 2026 Session to Uncover the Missing Data That's Costing Fleets at Disposal

Work trucks lose value at remarketing, not because they aren't worth more, but because the data to prove it rarely makes it to the auction.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A rental car rolling through a UVeye overhead vehicle inspection terminal.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseMarch 13, 2026

TSD Mobility, UVeye Partner On Automated Vehicle Inspections

The enhanced technology allows rental car operations, dealerships, and auctions to compare a vehicle’s condition at pickup and drop-off within the same rental or loaner record.

Read More →
Graphic promoting a CAR 2026 conference session showing four speaker headshots above the title “What Really Moves Vehicle Value Now — And What Doesn’t” with automotive conference branding
Operationsby Chris BrownMarch 11, 2026

CAR 2026: What Really Moves Vehicle Value Now — And What Doesn’t

A panel at the 2026 Conference of Automotive Remarketing will examine how resale value is created across the vehicle lifecycle and which traditional remarketing practices still deliver ROI.

Read More →
A collage of two photos of day cab trucks above a checklist for maximizing resale values.
Used Vehicle ValuesMarch 1, 2026

How To Maximize TCO and Resale Value in Day Cab Fleets

Smart operational and spec'ing decisions can dramatically improve both the total cost of ownership during use and the resale value when it's time to remarket day cabs.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Image of rows of cars and a shopping cart.
Used Vehicle Valuesby Chris BrownMarch 1, 2026

How to Drive Better Returns on De-Fleeted Vehicles in 2026

Smart remarketing begins before vehicles enter the fleet, and is built on strong data and stronger FMC partnerships.

Read More →