J.D. Power and Associates: Vehicle History Reports are Becoming Increasingly Important to Used-Vehicle Buyers
WESTLAKE VILLAGE, CA – As last year's hurricanes cause concern about flood-damaged vehicles potentially appearing on the market, vehicle history reports are becoming an increasingly important tool among used-vehicle buyers, according to the J.D. Power and Associates 2006 Used Vehicle Sales and Certification (UVSC) Study.
WESTLAKE VILLAGE, CA – As last year’s hurricanes cause concern about flood-damaged vehicles potentially appearing on the market, vehicle history reports are becoming an increasingly important tool among used-vehicle buyers, according to the J.D. Power and Associates 2006 Used Vehicle Sales and Certification (UVSC) Study.
The study, now in its fifth year, finds that 34 percent of used-vehicle buyers report obtaining a vehicle history report (VHR) before purchasing their vehicle-up from 30 percent in 2005. Additionally, 57 percent of respondents say they would refuse to purchase a used vehicle without a VHR-up from 53 percent in 2005.
“Vehicle history reports are an inexpensive way to ease the concerns of consumers about potentially buying a vehicle that may have been heavily damaged in a hurricane or other natural disaster,” said Jane Crane, director of automotive retail research at J.D. Power and Associates. “Approximately 30 percent of manufacturer franchise dealers are opting to provide vehicle history reports to potential buyers at no charge. This gesture of goodwill can go far in earning the buyer’s trust by showing that the dealer has nothing to hide.”
Another way consumers often alleviate the fears associated with buying a used vehicle is by purchasing a manufacturer-sponsored certified pre-owned (CPO) vehicle. Consumers typically pay an average premium of $1,680 for CPO vehicles, which have passed through extensive inspections and often include extended warranties. However, the study finds that certified used-vehicle buyers are less satisfied compared to 2005 with the price paid for the vehicle.
“In light of the large incentives many manufacturers were offering buyers of new vehicles in 2005, it may have been harder to convince used-vehicle buyers that this premium was worth it,” said Crane. “Dealerships have to work hard to communicate the value of certification to their customers and have strong policies in place to follow through on CPO warranties. This can go far in keeping customers satisfied, which increases the likelihood of the customer recommending the dealer to others and returning to the dealership for future vehicle service.”
With fuel prices continuing to rise and sales of new hybrid-electric vehicles increasing every year, many consumers are turning their attention to used hybrid vehicles. The study finds that 44 percent of late-model used-vehicle buyers are willing to consider a pre-owned hybrid-electric vehicle rather than a traditional gasoline-powered vehicle, even at an additional cost. Major concerns that used-vehicle buyers have with considering used hybrid-electric vehicles are the estimated higher maintenance costs, reliability, and the lifespan of the vehicle’s battery pack.
“Previously owned hybrids are perfect candidates for certification programs, where in-depth inspections and longer warranties help alleviate the concerns of buyers about purchasing used hybrids,” said Crane.
The 2006 Used Vehicle Sales and Certification Study is based on responses from more than 12,800 used-vehicle owners who purchased a 2001 to 2006 model-year used vehicle that was registered between September and October 2005.
More Operations

FLD Promotes Three Executives in Leadership Changes
FLD has promoted three longtime executives, naming Gary Mott CEO, Richard Mallek president, and Ron Sanders managing partner.
Read More →
CAS Automotive Launches Remarketing Service for Damaged, Surplus Equipment
Damaged Equipment expands CAS Automotive’s vehicle remarketing model to commercial equipment, targeting fleet operators, insurers, equipment dealers, and rental companies.
Read More →
Fleet Sales Hold Steady as Commercial Gains Offset Rental Decline
Commercial and government fleet sales increased through July 2026, offsetting most of the decline in rental volume and leaving combined comparable fleet sales 0.5% above the same period last year.
Read More →
Personnel Update: BrickHouse GPS, PRO-VISION, Auto Driveaway, and Proaction
Check out the latest must-know fleet personnel updates from the last couple of months.
Read More →
What Comes Next for Auto Driveaway?
A new Auto Driveaway feature called Arrive provides recipients with live location updates and ETAs during the final hour of a vehicle move, while fleet customers continue to have end-to-end shipment visibility through the company's customer portal.
Read More →
Manheim Index Shows Used-Vehicle Wholesale Prices Up 2.1% in June
The market is seeing stronger appreciation in older used vehicles this year, and the most affordable segments have been among the year’s best performers.
Read More →
Commercial Fleet Sales Contribute To June, YTD Gains
The fleet sector has boosted its vehicle purchases at a reliable pace in the first half of this year compared with 1H 2025.
Read More →
Stop Remarketing Electric Vehicles Like Gas Cars
The advantages and attributes of electric vehicles are upending the traditional remarketing cycle, requiring fleet sellers to rely on new factors and approaches detailed below.
Read More →
AP Fleet Management Expands Remarketing Program for Commercial Work Trucks
AP Fleet Management expanded its commercial vehicle remarketing program with dedicated resale services and an online marketplace for used work trucks.
Read More →
Used EVs Strengthen Overall Electric Vehicle Market
The latest sales data point to several reasons for the divergent trends in new and used EVs that can factor into fleet cycling decisions.
Read More →