Vehicle Remarketing Logo

'Play it Again, Sam' or Can You Hum a Few Bars of Depreciation Blues?

Fleet managers have been pursuing cost savings forever. You're right. What is surprising to me is that in this era of virtual deflation for running costs (cheap gas) and the competition between outsourcing service companies as well as the street and sole-source incentives from the makers, where is one to look.

Ed Bobit
Ed BobitFormer Editor & Publisher
June 1, 1998
'Play it Again, Sam' or Can You Hum a Few Bars of Depreciation Blues?

Ed Bobit, 1998

3 min to read


Ed Bobit, 1998

At last month's NAFA Fleet Institute in Seattle one had to go back home with a good feeling. All to NAFA's credit, it was probably the best educational program in years, with competent, speakers and moderators which all led to a great attendance and participation.

You missed an unusual opportunity to learn if you were not there. Seattle is a beautiful city, especially with the sunshine we were blessed with.

Ad Loading...

I might also add that many felt the AFLA Conference was also the best in years with record attendees.

With our deep involvement for several of our magazine titles in the fleet market, we sent a bevy of our editors to get the pulse of the industry. (Besides all the cocktail receptions informally known as "hospitality suites" that never seem to close).

This year we asked our editors to talk to fleet managers and ask our "Man-in-the-Aisle" question: "What is the major issue facing you at this time?"

Our dedicated guys came back with nearly 100 responses. While some voiced more than one, the single dominant issue was "cost containment."

Not surprising, you say? Fleet managers have been pursuing cost savings forever. You're right. What is surprising to me is that in this era of virtual deflation for running costs (cheap gas) and the competition between outsourcing service companies as well as the street and sole-source incentives from the makers, where is one to look.

Ad Loading...

I'd like to give you a clue.

If you give a few critical moments to my three simple charts you will note that over the past couple of years recovered residuals have decreased from 46 percent to 40 percent while initial costs have inched up somewhat. Think about it.

You are paying more for the new ones and getting back less. Your actual costs for depreciation have, increased nearly $2,000 per car.

How's that for a kick in the pants?

Instead of going into that budget meeting announcing your cost containment prowess as a vigilant watchdog or wave some rebate check, you face the consternation of executives who squirm at the fact that they've got to come up with nearly $l,700/car more than they did just two years ago at the turn.

Ad Loading...

Paraphrasing the infamous former Sen. Everett Dirkson (R-IL), "You lose a million here, and a million there, hell, pretty soon it starts to add up."

I sincerely hope, for your sake, that you have been avidly reading our many features on remarketing and my many editorials on depreciation costs being the one most important area for true fleet management; i.e. "The rest is detail."

I hope that you know all the auction lane buzzwords; I hope you how to read Black Book, Kelley, AMR and the rest of the guidebooks. I hope that you are an expert in analyzing your outsource service company on channels and comparative residuals in their remarketing assignment. I hope that you make a conscious effort to direct your drivers to turn in a clean car.

Just know this: with the strong retail incentives and the very special leasing rates available to consumers, you have probably seen the last of unusually high residuals for a while. And it will undoubtedly get. worse with maker overcapacity and share of market goals.

It's no wonder so many are running their cars longer. I also hope you're on very good terms with your boss.

Originally posted on Automotive Fleet

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Fleet

Collage of CAR speakers
Used Vehicle Valuesby Chris BrownApril 27, 2026

CAR2026 in Two Words: Velocity, Value (Part 1)

The 2026 Conference of Automotive Remarketing convened with a mandate to involve a new constituency — fleet managers — and an updated mission to demonstrate unrealized value in de-fleeted vehicles.

Read More →
Fleet Remarketing Association temp logo
Fleetby Chris BrownApril 20, 2026

Launch of Fleet Remarketing Association Signals New Era for Vehicle Lifecycle Value and Data Stewardship

The Association, dedicated to advancing the remarketing phase of the vehicle lifecycle, held its kick-off meeting on April 16 at the 2026 Conference of Automotive Remarketing (CAR) in Cleveland.

Read More →
Line comparisons of used vehicle inventory set in different colors.
Fleetby News/Media ReleaseApril 20, 2026

March Used Vehicle Inventory Falls To Lowest Since 2019

Franchised and independent dealers had a total of 1.95 million used vehicles in stock in March, the lowest on record in the current data set.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Green and black bar graphs showing March 2025 versus March 2026 commercial fleet sales.
Fleetby Martin RomjueApril 2, 2026

Quarterly, Monthly Commercial Fleet Sales Flying Higher

The fleet sector is performing stronger than last year, outpacing the rental and government fleet sectors.

Read More →
Graphic promoting CAR 2026 roundtables featuring headshots of five speakers and topics including Wall Street trends, fleet data, upfits, fair market value, and AI in remarketing.
Operationsby Chris BrownMarch 31, 2026

CAR 2026: Get the Wall Street Update on the Key Players in Remarketing

From a Wall Street analyst's take on remarketing's key players to whether fleets need their own version of Carfax, CAR 2026's afternoon roundtables will answer key operational and industry questions.

Read More →
Promotional graphic for CAR 2026 panel on data-driven value in commercial vehicles, featuring five industry experts and session details for April 16 in Cleveland.
Fleetby Chris BrownMarch 31, 2026

CAR 2026 Session to Uncover the Missing Data That's Costing Fleets at Disposal

Work trucks lose value at remarketing, not because they aren't worth more, but because the data to prove it rarely makes it to the auction.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Chart highlighting February EV sales trends, showing a decline in new EV sales and growth in used EV sales based on Cox Automotive market data.
Fleetby News/Media ReleaseMarch 19, 2026

EV Market Feeling The New Reality Of Steep Losses

New EV sales declined year over year in February while used EV demand rose, as prices fell and inventory tightened across both segments.

Read More →
Technician handling electric vehicle battery components in a recycling facility as Cox Automotive expands EV battery processing and material recovery operations.
Fleetby News/Media ReleaseMarch 17, 2026

Cox Automotive Amasses EV Battery Minerals

The company has processed more than 10 million pounds of EV battery black mass, highlighting growing demand for recycling and lifecycle management as more electric vehicles enter the used market.

Read More →
Graphic promoting a CAR 2026 conference session showing four speaker headshots above the title “What Really Moves Vehicle Value Now — And What Doesn’t” with automotive conference branding
Operationsby Chris BrownMarch 11, 2026

CAR 2026: What Really Moves Vehicle Value Now — And What Doesn’t

A panel at the 2026 Conference of Automotive Remarketing will examine how resale value is created across the vehicle lifecycle and which traditional remarketing practices still deliver ROI.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Blue bar graphs showing a rise in used vehicle categories across the board.

Wholesale Used Vehicle Prices Up In February

Solid demand at Manheim auctions with higher sales conversion rates indicate an appetite from dealers to buy.

Read More →